Modern RF designs are moving beyond traditional quartz crystal oscillator solutions. The industry is shifting towards digital compensation techniques, and now developers are presented with a new range of considerations when selecting ideal timing solutions.
From material properties to integration capabilities, high-performance timing systems are increasingly being characterized more by performance parameters than legacy terminology. To maintain a competitive edge, standards organizations and manufacturers must address the evolution head-on to leverage the advantages of modern architectures.
What is an Oscillator?
At its core, an oscillator is a closed-loop system designed to convert DC power into a periodic AC signal of a specific frequency. The generation of this signal relies on two fundamental components: an amplifying element (active device) and a frequency-determining network (resonator).
What is a Resonator?
A resonator is a device or circuit element that exhibits a peak response, usually a large amplitude, when activated at specific frequencies. Known as resonant frequencies, this behavior is exhibited due to the properties of the material or system. A resonator essentially selectively stores and exchanges energy between its reactive components with minimal losses over each cycle of oscillation.
Any structure that has resonance can serve as the frequency-determining network in an oscillator, and materials with piezoelectric properties are particularly useful for use in applications requiring precision timing.
Piezoelectric Effects in Resonators
The piezoelectric effect is a property in certain materials where mechanical stress generates an electric charge, and vice versa. In resonance, the benefit of utilizing piezoelectric materials is that their crystalline structure limits variation during the period it takes for materials to compress and relax. This establishes an accurate time base with known properties.
Resonator Alternatives
For the last 100 years, quartz has been primarily used the default material of choice for many applications where an oscillator is required due to its reliability, ease of implementation, and availability. However, many other resonator types exist and can be more suitable for use in specific applications.
LC Circuits
One of the most basic resonator types is an LC circuit, where inductors (L) and capacitors (C) create a tank circuit. At the resonant frequency, the inductive reactance equals the capacitive reactance in magnitude but is 180° out of phase. This results in a theoretically infinite impedance in an ideal lossless circuit. In practice, resistive losses limit the performance of LC Circuits, making them uncommon for use in practical oscillators.
Ceramic Resonators
Ceramic Resonators have found their way into many consumer-based applications, particularly white goods, where they are used to drive lower accuracy timing requirements. For example, ceramic resonators are low-cost alternatives that are attractive in applications like washing machine program controllers, where timing is measured in seconds.
Quartz Resonators
Quartz resonators are ideal solutions in timing applications because of their excellent frequency stability and low phase noise. The resonant frequency of quartz is inversely proportional to the thickness of the material, making it impractical to create fundamental mode quartz resonators at frequencies much higher than about 80MHz, as the material becomes too fragile. There are complex manufacturing techniques that can extend this frequency higher with an associated cost.
SAW Resonators
SAW resonators use acoustic waves that travel along the surface of a piezoelectric substrate. Their design involves interdigitated transducers (IDTs) that convert electrical signals to mechanical waves and vice versa. Taking advantage of both quartz and other more exotic materials, SAW resonators have resonant frequencies that are significantly higher than those of quartz, between 100MHz and 2GHz.
BAW Resonators
Unlike SAW, BAW devices use vibrations that propagate through the bulk of piezoelectric material. Quartz utilizes bulk mode resonance, but the term ‘BAW Resonator’ typically refers to resonators using more exotic piezoelectric materials such as aluminum nitride. BAW resonators can operate at very high frequencies, between 1GHz and 10GHz in fundamental mode.
MEMS Resonators
Micro-Electro-Mechanical Systems (MEMS) resonators are fabricated using lithographic processes to etch micromachined, flexure structures to achieve mechanical resonance, typically on silicon. Silicon is not a commonly considered material if design requirements include low phase noise or high frequency stability. However, the appeal of embedding resonators in semiconductors has driven investment in both resonator design and the oscillator circuit compensation techniques that are required to enhance accuracy.
Traditional Oscillator Solutions
Over the past century, oscillator design has transitioned from the use of quartz resonators, almost exclusively, to resonator structures previously discussed. Historically, the terminology used—XO, TCXO, and OCXO—was closely tied to quartz crystals’ inherent characteristics and environments.
Today, advancements in MEMS, SAW, BAW, and other resonator structures, along with advanced compensation techniques, render these classifications less suitable and likely to evolve soon.
The traditional oscillator definitions based on quartz resonators are as follows:
Crystal Oscillators (XO)
Crystal Oscillators (XO) are basic oscillator configurations that utilize quartz crystals without specialized temperature adjustments. The determined frequency is defined by the crystal’s physical dimensions and cut (e.g., AT or SC). It exhibits drift purely based on intrinsic properties and environmental influences.
Temperature-Compensated Crystal Oscillator (TCXO)
To mitigate frequency shifts due to temperature variations, TCXOs incorporate analog and digital compensation networks.
Oven-Controlled Crystal Oscillator (OCXO)
Taking temperature control a step further, OCXOs house a quartz crystal in a thermally isolated oven. The oven maintains the resonator at an optimum constant temperature, higher than the operating temperature. This method significantly reduces temperature-induced frequency drift and phase noise but comes with trade-offs, such as increased power consumption, warm-up time, size, and cost.
The Future of Digital Temperature Compensation in RF Design
Early frequency compensation techniques for quartz-based resonators were inherently analog. Passive components like RC networks, diode-based circuits, thermistors, etc. provided rudimentary correction by exploiting predictable temperature coefficients in quartz.
Still implemented in some applications today, these designs were effective. However, digital control has mostly replaced analog compensation in oscillator designs, enabling the efficient use of BAW, SAW, and MEMS resonators in next-generation oscillators.
Digital temperature compensation involves real-time monitoring of temperature using integrated sensors. A microcontroller or dedicated digital signal processor (DSP) runs compensation algorithms that adjust an oscillator’s frequency. These adjustments are made through voltage-controlled elements or frequency synthesis, providing:
- Enhanced Precision: Greater accuracy in responding to non-linear temperature effects.
- Adaptability: The ability to learn and predict frequency drift over time using calibration data.
- Integration Benefits: Digital compensation circuits can be integrated on the same chip, reducing overall system size and cost.
- Feedback and Adaptive Algorithms: Modern oscillators often use advanced feedback loops instead of traditional analog compensation networks. Algorithms that analyze historical drift data and real-time sensor inputs drive correction circuits to counteract temperature variations, aging, and other environmental factors. A digital approach enables robust performance even under conditions that would overwhelm traditional compensation techniques.
- Performance Metrics Over Nomenclature: Whilst system engineers often define their Oscillator needs based on the traditional compensation terminology, defining, their system needs are often quantified by oscillator performance using metrics such as phase noise, Allan deviation, temperature drift, jitter, and power consumption. This leaves room for a broader classification scheme that can encompass emerging technologies under a unified performance standard.
Adapt to New Design Requirements with RFMW Technical Expertise
The evolution of oscillator technologies reflects a broader trend in electronics—from hardware-bound, analog approaches towards highly integrated, digitally controlled systems that offer unparalleled precision. Traditional quartz-based timing solutions provided a clear description of compensation methodologies in the past, but modern oscillator solutions utilizing novel resonator structures challenge these definitions due to their diverse operating principles and compensation techniques.
Timing systems will increasingly be defined by performance metrics rather than traditional nomenclature.
Fortunately, RFMW is uniquely positioned to support developers navigating new timing solutions. Our comprehensive team of technical experts understands the complexities of timing components within RF industry dynamics, from supply chain considerations to the latest advancements. We are a go-to resource for overcoming modern RF challenges, capitalizing on emerging trends, and driving innovation.
More Articles About Timing Products
RFMW Expert Product Pick: SiTime SiT7111 and SiT7112 OCXOs
SiTime’s SIT5346 Endura™ Oscillator Selected for Expert Product Pick
About Colin Field
Colin Field is an RFMW Supplier Business Manager responsible for passive components with a particular focus on RF Filters and antenna solutions. Beginning his career in 1984, Colin has a passion for physics which has led to a lifelong interest in materials technology, properties and the potential uses and applications of those materials.
